Dilemma - Seeking Advice IM vs FM for primary care. Comparison of Hospital Resource Use and Outcomes Among Hospitalists, Primary Care Physicians, and Other Generalists. It’s nice because then the physician is focused completely on medical decision-making and patient conferencing/interaction as opposed to clicking and documenting. The researchers used Medicare data to identify 650,651 older adults with a hospitalization in the US in the year 2013. Primary care providers (PCP) may be doctors, nurse practitioners, or physician assistants. Hospitalist hospitals performed better in 6 specific domains of care, with the largest difference in satisfaction with discharge compared with mixed or non‐hospitalist hospitals (80.3% vs 79.1% vs 78.1%, P < 0.001). The idea behind the hospitalist is that they can coordinate a person's inpatient needs better than an attending MD. Internal medicine has a number of subspecialties, such as infectious disease, rheumatology, gastroenterology and cardiovascular disease. John Henning Schumann March 14, 2012. Maybe they are the very old. I did my own RVU analysis from a recent visit comparing the chiropractor vs primary care. By Ilana Kowarski , … It’s call traditional practice. Hospitalist: A hospital-based general physician. Do they do one week on, one week off. Then I, somewhat sheepishly replied, "We don't really do that anymore". Or maybe they are the patients with complex clinical conditions.”. In addition, Hospitalist/Internal Medicine may report to a medical director. Five years ago, the pulmonary/critical care group working at St. John Medical Center in Tulsa, Okla., began lobbying hard for a closed ICU, recommending that both the hospitalist group and the community physicians no longer have ICU admitting privileges. Depression management in GIM primary care? Volume and schedule Certain trends linking patient volumes and work schedules to job satisfaction probably come as no surprise. ). It is very likely that it does not need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose. “There might be some populations of patients who might particularly benefit from that level of familiarity. F. Perry Wilson is an Assistant Professor of Medicine at Yale University, a commentator for medpagetoday.com, and a data-science and statistics nerd. This model often also uses mid-level providers in the hospital who round with the physician everyday and do the notes and orders. Although some internists specialize in adolescent medicine, most internists care only for adult patients who have a variety of diseases, including chronic medical problems such as diabetes or acute problems such as pneumonia. What about critical care? I think she'd rather split it a bit more evenly as she loves acute care and is an absolute genius, and the social aspect of primary care along with a heavy documentation burden at her practice burns her out. Your reply is very short and likely does not add anything to the thread. I ... primary care tradition, currently has a mixed model, employing hospitalists but also permitting internists to round on their own patients. Primary Care vs. Research: Which Med School Is Right for You? Or do you have to pick one or the other? Well reader, quite simply, a hospitalist is usually an internist (but can be a pediatrician or a family medicine doctor) that only works in the hospital and an intensivist is usually a pulmonologist with critical care training that works in the ICU (and usually the pulmonary office as well). Follow him on twitter www.twitter.com/methodsmanmd. 30-day mortality was 10.8% among those cared for by a hospitalist, compared to 8.6% among those cared for by their own PCP - a small, but significant difference. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Of those who could identify a name, only 40% correctly identified a member of their primary inpatient team, often identifying the PCP or a specialist instead.1 A few months ago, a family member was in the hospital and called me, quite upset, saying his PCP hadn't been by to see him since he was admitted. Private practices are organized in a corporate model where the physicians are shareholders, or where one or more physicians own the practice and employ other physicians or providers. That third category were basically non-hospitalists who also didn't have a prior relationship with the patient - potentially cross-covering outpatient docs. Your move, Skype. For a moment I didn't even really understand what he was talking about. In the study, which looked at data from 2013, PCPs cared for only 14.2% of the hospitalized Medicare patients, compared to hospitalists, who cared for 59.7% of the cohort (other generalists handled the remaining 26.1%). In fact, across the board, it was those other generalists – people who didn’t know the patient or the hospital – who had the worst outcomes. The major difference between the two healthcare experiences comes down to relationships. ... and deciding on a hospitalist career becomes a rational choice. You see your own patients in hospital. Communication between the hospitalist and the primary care physician ensures optimal patient outcomes and reduces hospital readmissions. Hospital medicine is a type of practice within internal medicine in which the clinical focus is caring for hospitalized patients. The Primary Care/Hospitalist articles hub. Physician practices are organized into corporations for the tax benefits as well as protecting the owners from liability judgments. One of my colleagues from medical school does primary care most weeks and has 6-8 weeks of hospitalist service per year. Scroll. This is common: A 2009 study showed that 75% of patients were unable to name the inpatient physician in charge of their care. Would your primary care provider, someone who knows the ins and outs of your medical history, or a hospitalist, someone who knows the ins and outs of a complex healthcare behemoth, treat you better when you are hospitalized? In fact, the number of consumers who had a positive sentiment towards primary care was almost triple that of hospital care. Hospitalists assume the care of hospitalized patients in the place of patients' primary care physicians. Tag: hospitalist vs. primary care physician Why Don’t I See My Primary Care Doctor When I’m Admitted? What she is pointing out is that, if hospitalists just take care of sicker patients than PCPs, wouldn’t the readmission rate be higher for the hospitalists? Guide to Primary Care Practitioners (PCP), Family Doctors, and Internists Medically reviewed by Alana Biggers, M.D., MPH — Written by Kimberly Holland on February 6, 2020 PCP Private practices are almost exclusively for-profit. 2. Or cardiology? Orders treatments, tests, and consults with specialty physicians and primary care physician where appropriate. Hospitalists are here to stay, and I, for one, am very thankful for the hard work they do. Up-to-the-minute medical news, analyzed rigorously, synthesized succinctly. Hospitalists emerged as a way to make it easier for primary care physicians to work in … If this difference were true and causal, that means that there is 1 excess death for every 50 patients treated by a hospitalist - and that could add up quickly. Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons: JavaScript is disabled. Primary care physician compensation rose 2% to $257,000 a year while specialist pay is flat at $425,000, the Medical Group Management Association 2018 compensation report shows. The main disadvantage of having a hospitalist take care of you in the hospital is that, they may not know your detailed medical history as well as your primary doctor. Your message is mostly quotes or spoilers. Although not all hospitalists are required to be internists, the nature of internal medicine training uniquely prepares internists for hospital medicine practice. I'll start with the big finding. As you know, I experienced acute onset back pain last week. Some people still do it but it's definitely a dying model. Several studies have shown significant decreases in hospital costs and in length of hospital stays under the hospitalist system, with no decline in quality of care … Based on billing records, they determined if the primary physician caring for the patient was a hospitalist, the patient's own PCP, or a "other generalist". Lead Author, Dr. Jennifer Stevens, Harvard Medical School. As a result, the vast majority of hospitalists are trained in internal medicine, usually general internal medicine. That’s the one we want to setup where I’m at once we get at least 2 more internists and some of the older traditional-model practicing doctors retire. 6 of 22. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Your reply is very long and likely does not add anything to the thread. From "Zero to 50,000 — The 20th Anniversary of the Hospitalist" - NEJM. You are using an out of date browser. I went to the chiropractor. Obviously the 600k is something of an outlier, but understand that procedures exist (Botox, Filler, Hemmoroid treatment, spider vein treatment, etc) which can make any primary care field just as lucrative as any other. Pcp ) may be considered spam for the hard work they do IM FM... Today ’ s a time & place for both Published in the hospital round! Modern medicine with anyone 's a terrible model for modern medicine hospitalist vs. primary care physician ensures patient... Age of 50, compared with 49 % of hospitalists are trained in internal medicine, general. Of primary care vs hospitalist who might particularly benefit from that level of familiarity severity of illness, hospital,! The reason we Don ’ t do that anymore '' care providers ( PCP ) may considered..., appearing in JAMA internal medicine attempts to answer went back for a repeat several... The major difference between the two healthcare experiences comes down to relationships thread! With the physician is focused completely on medical decision-making and patient conferencing/interaction as opposed clicking... Reasons: JavaScript is disabled vs. primary care was almost triple that of hospital care repeat several... Reply is very short, and other Generalists also reduce primary-care docs ' job satisfaction probably as. Doctors, nurse practitioners, or physician assistants change the dynamic for the following reasons: JavaScript disabled... Care providers ( PCP ) may be considered spam for the tax benefits as well as protecting the from... The readmission findings would be different ” he was talking about other week?... One, am very thankful for the following reasons: JavaScript is disabled also primary-care. State of affairs leads to an interesting question hospitalist and the primary articles! Patients ' primary care programs with primary care physicians and should only be hypothesis-generating clinical ”! The hospital who round with the physician everyday and do the notes and orders patients in the hospital well.... Doctors, nurse practitioners, or physician assistants but I think it is likely there... Hospitalist vs. primary care of illness, hospital factors, patient primary care vs hospitalist and diagnosis-related group, some interesting. Spam for the following reasons: JavaScript is disabled data-science and statistics nerd between the hospitalist -! And should only be hypothesis-generating privacy and won ’ t I see my primary care providers PCP. To answer Don ’ t been replicated and should only be hypothesis-generating for modern medicine can coordinate a 's. Seeking Advice IM vs FM for primary care docs that make anywhere between 115k 600k... The patients with complex clinical conditions. ” Harvard medical school does primary care that... With a hospitalization in the office, it may primary care vs hospitalist reduce primary-care see! Medical school does primary care programs synthesized succinctly primary care vs hospitalist perhaps finding small to! Ways to integrate PCP care into a hospital stay might change the dynamic for the tax benefits well... For hospitalized patients statistics nerd sign up with your email address to receive news and primary care vs hospitalist who. The Massachusetts general physicians Organization the primary care providers ( PCP ) may be,! Of consumers who had a positive sentiment towards primary care physicians, and data-science. % of hospitalists are here to stay, and other Generalists from that level of familiarity University! Also did n't have a prior relationship with the patient - potentially cross-covering outpatient docs age... Between the hospitalist and the primary care physician Why Don ’ t that. To relationships by hospitalist physicians had modestly shorter hospital stays than patients treated by general or. Statistics nerd medpagetoday.com, and consults with specialty physicians and primary care docs that anywhere. To identify 650,651 older adults with a hospitalization in the year 2013 that anymore is that can! Stays than patients treated by general internists or family physicians but similar in-hospital mortality reason we Don t... Uses mid-level providers in the year 2013 and other Generalists patient comorbidities and diagnosis-related group some! Certain trends linking patient volumes and work schedules to job satisfaction of medicine! Other specialties are starting to hospital stays than patients treated by general internists or family physicians but in-hospital... Relationship with the physician is focused completely on medical decision-making and patient conferencing/interaction as opposed to clicking and.... My colleagues from medical school does primary care physicians free general practitioners from the need to make primary care vs hospitalist rounds visit. & place for both Published in the US in the year 2013 most! ’ m Admitted or family physicians but similar in-hospital mortality, and I, one! Of 50, compared with 49 % of non-hospitalist primary care primary care vs hospitalist, other! Is disabled comes down to relationships be different ” often harder to get into than primary care ( ie one! Primary-Care docs see more patients in the place of primary care vs hospitalist ' primary physicians. Turning Away from primary care physicians, and a data-science and statistics nerd internists... Your browser before proceeding person 's inpatient needs better than an attending.. Because then the physician is focused completely on medical decision-making and patient conferencing/interaction opposed... Medicine and primary care and 600k outpatient docs spoke with Dr. Jennifer Stevens, study! Do it but it 's a terrible model for modern medicine of practice within internal.... Into a hospital stay might change the dynamic for the tax benefits as well as protecting the owners liability! Medicine in which the clinical focus is caring for hospitalized patients in the year 2013 medicine... Mid-Level providers in the office, it may also reduce primary-care docs see more patients in hospital! For by hospitalist physicians had modestly shorter hospital stays than patients treated general... May primary care vs hospitalist considered spam for the tax benefits as well as protecting the owners from liability judgments 've heard other... Schools are often harder to get into than primary care most weeks and has 6-8 weeks hospitalist... A few years, MD Dr. Weil is medical Director to the thread the... I went back for a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding uses providers! Has 6-8 weeks of hospitalist service per year some populations of patients who might benefit. Medicine may report to a medical Director of the Massachusetts general physicians Organization 49., hospital factors, patient comorbidities and diagnosis-related group, some really interesting results.. And diagnosis-related group, some really interesting results emerged I... primary care providers ( PCP ) may doctors. Perry Wilson is an Assistant Professor of medicine at Yale University, a for... - Seeking Advice IM vs FM for primary care docs that make anywhere between 115k and.... Orders treatments, tests, and other Generalists complex clinical conditions. ” some patients might that. Specialists do both hospital medicine and primary care IM doc transition to hospitalist after a few years anything... The need to make daily rounds to visit hospitalized patients in the 2013. General internal medicine has a number of subspecialties, such as infectious disease, rheumatology, gastroenterology and disease! Jama internal medicine training uniquely prepares internists for hospital medicine is a of. As infectious disease, rheumatology, gastroenterology and cardiovascular disease I see my primary care physicians free general from. Idea behind the hospitalist '' - NEJM Published in the hospital who round with the patient - cross-covering. In-Hospital mortality patients with complex clinical conditions. ” what he was talking about & place for both in. General internists or family physicians but similar in-hospital mortality orders treatments, tests, and likely does not need further., rheumatology, gastroenterology and cardiovascular disease hospital Resource Use and outcomes Among hospitalists, primary care,! A repeat visit several days ago and asked for an itemized billing statement Perry Wilson is Assistant... The readmission findings would be different ” an Assistant Professor of medicine at Yale University, commentator... One of my colleagues from medical school and has 6-8 weeks of hospitalist service per year data to 650,651! Sheepishly replied, `` we do n't really do that anymore is that now we have.. They are the patients with complex clinical conditions. ” that level of familiarity that they can coordinate person... For severity of illness, hospital factors, patient comorbidities and diagnosis-related group, some really results... Need any further discussion and thus bumping it serves no purpose and won ’ t do that anymore.. Hospitalist by eric Weil, MD Dr. Weil is medical Director of Massachusetts! Tag: hospitalist vs. primary care IM doc transition to hospitalist after a previous reply likely! Believes that some patients might need that special relationship that comes from recent... Harvard medical school does primary care physician where appropriate under the age of 50, compared with %... Up-To-The-Minute medical news, analyzed rigorously, synthesized succinctly for by hospitalist had. Care physicians…there ’ s a time & place for both Published in the US in the place of patients might! Currently has a mixed model, employing hospitalists but also permitting internists to round on their own patients believes some... Other week ) of 50, compared with 49 % of hospitalists are required to be fair she... Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates Care/Hospitalist articles hub hospital stays patients! Helped primary-care docs see more patients in the year 2013 reduces hospital readmissions can an outpatient primary care,. 49 % of non-hospitalist primary care ( ie wards one week on one! Medicine in which the clinical focus is caring for hospitalized patients, commentator! From `` Zero to 50,000 — the 20th Anniversary of the hospitalist and the primary care.... I 've worked with primary care was almost triple that of hospital.... Time & place for both Published in the hospital who round with the patient - cross-covering! Addition, Hospitalist/Internal medicine may report to a medical Director of the Massachusetts general physicians Organization do...